Thursday 2 August 2012

Olympic Opening Ceremonies: London vs Beijing


I know many of you may disagree, but I think that London’s 2012 Olympic opening ceremony is better than then Beijing’s 2008 opening ceremony. Both had the same idea in mind though, to showcase each nation’s accomplishments and contributions to the world. However, it’s notable that Britain stayed clear from reminding the world that it used to conquer half of it.


China’s opening ceremony was awe inspiring. You get the sense of grandeur amid a very oriental setting. Undoubtedly China exploited it’s most abundant resource; its people. At the heart of all its creative showcases were actually humans frolicking around in the enormous bird nest stadium. They actually employed soldiers to run their clock-like precision performances. It’s everything a communist nation can be proud of; synchronized, uniformed, innumerable.


Fast forward to London, each participant seems to be an actor. Even the children know how to perform. Their dancing may not be militarily synchronized in motion, but they were synchronized in seemingly genuine smiles and spirit. In fact they emphasized fun like one large flash mob.


China’s repertoire was written to impress, one dazzling display after another. And it did just that. They focused on the length and breadth of the Chinese civilization and the four great inventions of the ancient Chinese: paper, printing, the compass and gunpowder.


The British attempted to do the same, start off with history and showcase their contributions to the world. However since a major part of their history involves many storied wars of the British Empire which was a naval powerhouse and master colonialist, they risk offending almost everyone who is not British. Hence, their summation on British history seems disjointed and incomplete.


We are left with scenes from ancient English village with farm animals and maypoles, the industrial revolution which Britain initiated, socialized medicine, and more recent cultural exports. The English village and industrial revolution scenes were evocative with Hollywood quality costumes and every bit as impressive as Beijing.


From Harry’s Potter’s stadium tall Voldemort battling an army of Mary Poppins to a brief appearance of Mr. Bean, the English flaunted their greatest cultural exports. And did you know the creator of the World Wide Web is British? And at times they tried to do too much. I adore British music, but in one sequence, they sampled a line from each song from the 1950s to 1980s and played it in one long annoying grating medley. That is undoubtedly everyone’s least favourite sequence.


And saving the best surprise for last is the torch lighting ceremony, where in recent years everyone tried to one up the predecessor. When the countries were parading into the stadium, each was carrying a weird horn like sculpture. There wasn’t an obvious cauldron in sight, but in the center of the stadium, these horns were mysteriously installed onto some spiky contraption. After the torch bearer lit a few horns, the spikes began to mechanically rotate towards the sky forming a most unanticipated cauldron. Spectacular. (Sydney is best though)

The cauldron is made up of many small torches.

But negatives aside, the British version of the opening ceremony is unexpected, exciting and most importantly fun. The dancing was real, the spirit seemed authentic and London doesn’t care about taking itself too seriously (Beijing). And that’s why I think London is better than Beijing.

5 comments:

  1. London was BORRRRINNNGGGG. Beijing was spectacularrrr. Even I have to admit this and I am from Yorkshire.
    And your generalization about the faces of the Beijing performers are so sterotypical, don't you think it's a little bit racist to think they look that way because of your own biased opinions of the Communist system?
    Insulting, biased, racist. EXACTLY what the 2012 Olympics is like in London. It has got to be the messiest Olympics I have witnessed yet (from drug allegations to the innocent, wrong flags being shown, wrong national athems being played, matches being thrown out, biased judging, drama, drama and MORE drama)
    Disgrace.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. OK granted, it is disorganized. But that Danny Boyle did something different, he focused on the camera angle. So while from the stadium looking down on the crowd, it does look like a mess. It looks good on camera, to me at least.

      There might be a word to describe it: eccentric. I like it coz i'm eccentric as well. I get a little turned off when people try to show off too much.

      Beijing is a little too showy. South Africa was pretty good. And i'm only talking about the ceremony, not the drugs etc.

      And I'm not racist, because I'm Chinese myself, but not China Chinese.

      Delete
    2. Honestly, it was the WORST Olympic ever. I think that since your Chinese you should at least mention the unfair judges and poor poor Chen YiBing

      Delete
  2. Beijing was 1000% better than London. You don't need to be Chinese or Asian to see how much hard work, dedication & pride of the volunteers/ planners, etc. to execute the 2008 Olympics. If you can't see & acknowledge that, than you are just plain ignorant.

    ReplyDelete
  3. you can not compare at all, London had the worst job ever in having to take the Olympic Flag from Beijing! The question that every single country said was " Poor London, how on earth can they complete with that, we feel for them" and we did exactly the opposite! London never competed, it showed its own history in a very different way! Beijing demonstrated its comunist country with precission and detail, them poor troops had to spend 10 hours a day for 9 months in the boxes to get in absoulty pitch perfect! Children singing well miming becuase the original girl was to ugly to appear on TV ? No london could not and did not want to compete with that, London had a budget of 27M compared to Beijing 200M! instead they upstaged Beijing, not techically or with detail and fancy fireworks ( oh and for anyone watching at home that night, them fantastic Olympic rings seen exploding over the city ? well that was visual for us at home it never actually happend great ehh ? ) anyways I digress, London upstaged in everything else and more importantly with human emotion and soul!, you actually felt emotion during the industry revolution, the forging of the rings has to be the best ever done and you cannot not say no, just go back on you tube and see for yourself!! same goes wit hthe lighting of the torch, the NHS kiddies bouncing on beds with real nurses and doctors ( not military or actors ) real NHS staff who volenteer ) fighting fairy tale baddies whilst a zillion mary poppings coming floating out the sky to save the day!!! it was by far the most human, sincere, eccentric, moving ceremony I have ever seen! It goes to shoe, you dont money to impress, have a heart and it goes much further.

    ReplyDelete